Showcasing model Muslims confirmed rather than countered Islamophobic stereotypes [contrarian]
Journalist Nesrine Malik pinpointed how Clinton carried forward the central Islamophobic narrative that tethers Muslim identity tightly to terrorism, specifically, through the tokenization of Khizr and Ghazala Khan, the gold-star parents of fallen Army captain Humayun Khan. The Khans lost their son to a suicide-bomber attack in Iraq in 2004. Like thousands of other American families, the Khans had to move forward without a child lost to war. The Clinton campaign seized on their story and sought to showcase it and the Khans during the 2016 presidential campaign. In response to this, Malik observes, “Take the Khans of Hillary Clinton’s campaign, for example. They are liberal America’s final answer to the right’s toxic messaging and Trump’s ‘Muslim Ban’ electioneering. Rather than countering simplistic and reductionist views of Muslims, they confirmed them—something that was not lost on many, despite how desperate the situation was.”
XREF: Connects to broader critiques of 'positive stereotypes' and tokenism in liberal politics, similar to debates about 'model minority' framing.
Khaled A. Beydoun, American Islamophobia_ Unde…, loc. 349