I raise the topic of the uptick rule not to express a view. [contrarian]
I raise the topic of the uptick rule not to express a view on its desirability, but because it is an example of a general point: the financial and other markets of high modernity are to a significant extent entities subject to deliberate design, and the details of their design are consequential.
Donald MacKenzie, An Engine, Not a Camera, loc. 1235