Jamal Awil

← Islamophobia in America_ The Anatomy of…

Muslims wrestle with tensions between free speech and defending sacred texts. [fact]

Among Muslims, feelings were mixed. Many people believed Jones should be at liberty to do and say whatever he wanted, but people understood the desire to defend the Qur'an from injury. As a local school teacher told me, "My son said he would jump in to stop Jones from burning the Qur'an. I could not tell him this was wrong. I was proud of him. I wanted to support the way he felt, but I wanted to defend free speech. It was a strange moment for me." The idea that free speech exists on special terms in Dearborn, or that risking it was imprudent and possibly dangerous, was found among Islamophobes (who like to claim that Dearborn is ruled by Islamic law), among friends of the Arab/Muslim community (some of whom hold their current positions because Arab voters elected them), among members of the local ACLU, who denounced the court's ruling against Jones, and among Muslims who do not think anyone should be allowed to insult the Prophet Muhammad or his teachings.

Carl W. Ernst, Islamophobia in America_ Th…, loc. 677