Jamal Awil

← on individuality and social forms_…

A thinker's flawed works can still yield rich stimulation. [contrarian]

On the other hand, one finds oneself absolutely compelled to affirm that this mode of exposition is simply brilliant and, what is more important, attains results that are intrinsic to it and not to be attained by any imitator. Indeed, nearly every one of his works abounds in important new theoretical ideas and the most subtle observations. Almost every one of them belongs to those books in which not only the valid findings, but even the false ones, contain a wealth of stimulation for one's own further thought, in comparison with which the majority of even the most estimable accomplishments of other scholars often appear to exude a peculiar odor of scantiness and poverty.

XREF: This praise-heavy assessment of another scholar's work echoes the evaluative rhetoric found in academic prefaces and letters of recommendation.

Georg Simmel, on individuality and social…, loc. 115