Jamal Awil

← on individuality and social forms_…

Extreme religious individualism paradoxically suppresses individual differences in private life [contrarian]

As a whole, as a religious principle of the most extreme individualism and subjectivism, Quakerism binds members of the congregation to a style of life and a mode of being that are highly uniform and democratic, seeking to exclude, as far as possible, all individual differences. And in turn, Quakerism lacks all understanding for the higher political union and its goals so that the individuality of the smaller group not only precludes the individuality of the person, but also his commitment to the large group. The specific manifestation of this is as follows: in the affairs of the congregation, in the assemblies of worship, each person may act as preacher and may say whatever he likes whenever he likes. On the other hand, the congregation watches over personal affairs such as marriage, and these cannot occur without the permission of a committee that is appointed to investigate each case. Thus, the Quakers are individual only in collective matters, and in individual matters, they are socially regulated.

XREF: Evokes the classic paradox of collectivism versus individualism also found in Durkheim's work on religion and social cohesion. DEFINE: Clarifies the apparent contraction in Quakerism: freedom in collective worship combined with strict regulation of personal life.

Georg Simmel, on individuality and social…, loc. 611