Jamal Awil

← on individuality and social forms_…

Upper-class norms block both asking for and offering aid. [causal]

For this reason, no one is socially poor until he has been assisted. And this has a general validity: sociologically speaking, poverty does not come first and then assistance—this is rather fate in its personal form—but a person is called poor who receives assistance or should receive it given his sociological situation, although perchance he may not receive it.

DEFINE: Simmel offers a sociological definition of poverty as a status conferred by the welfare system, rather than a pre-existing material condition. QUESTION: This inverts the commonsense causal order — does this suggest welfare programs create the very category of 'the poor' they aim to serve?

DEFINE: The 'economic a priori' of a status class — the assumed baseline income below which poverty begins — defines who counts as déclassé.

Georg Simmel, on individuality and social…, loc. 444