Jamal Awil

← The Consequences of Modernity

Modernity increases rather than removes opacity in everyday life. [contrarian]

Sociologists often suppose that, in contrast to the pre-modern era, where many things were mysteries, today we live in a world from which mystery has retreated and where the way "the world works" can (in principle) be exhaustively known. But this is not true for either the lay person or the expert, if we consider their experience as individuals. To all of us living in the modern world things are specifically opaque, in a way that was not the case previously. In pre-modern environments the "local knowledge," to adapt a phrase from Clifford Geertz, which individuals possessed was rich, varied, and adapted to the requirements of living in the local milieu. But how many of us today when we switch on the light know much about where the electricity supply comes from or even, in a technical sense, what electricity actually is?

XREF: Connects to James C. Scott's work on local knowledge and tacit vs. codified expertise, as well as the Geertz reference the highlight itself adapts.

Anthony Giddens, The Consequences of Moderni…, loc. 348