Jamal Awil

← The Fear of Islam_ An Introduction to…

Western free-speech defenses do not extend equally to Muslims. [contrarian]

For example, many Western nations have intense debates about freedom of speech, and all set some limits on the scope of such speech. Some European countries have laws that prohibit Holocaust denial. One is not free in countries such as Belgium or Austria to deny or condone the genocide that took place in Nazi Germany. But when Muslims raise critical questions about the problems with speech that deliberately and disrespectfully denigrates the texts, figures, or practitioners of Islam, their views are often rejected outright. In 2005 and 2006, various Muslims inside and outside of Denmark raised such questions in response to satirical cartoons of Muhammad published by a Danish newspaper. Their questions were largely dismissed, with some public figures going so far as to point out that the real problem was the inability of Muslims to understand and accept the Western commitment to freedom of speech.

XREF: Connects to broader critiques of liberal universalism treating Western norms as neutral while excluding Muslim concerns.

Green, Todd H, The Fear of Islam_ An Intro…, loc. 67