Jamal Awil

← Trust and Trustworthiness

Survey trust questions may actually measure political cynicism. [contrarian]

Again, only one of these questions—the first—actually uses the term trust. The third question might elicit a judgment of policies more than of trust. The second and fourth questions address motivations that might bear on the trustworthiness of officials. As is true also for the General Social Survey questions, answers to these questions tend to be strongly correlated, so that it is sensible to claim that they are tapping something coherent even though it is arguably bold to assert that they tap a sense of trust in any particular conception of trust. Reputedly, when they were first added to the National Elections Studies battery, these questions were intended to tap political cynicism, not trust.

QUESTION: Worth exploring whether widely cited trust measures systematically conflate trust with cynicism, skewing research findings. XREF: Connects to methodological critiques of measurement validity in political science survey research.

Russell Hardin, Trust and Trustworthiness, loc. 897